Another controversial relationship that John Lloyd had was with the one and only Shaina. They became an official couple in 2010, just after John Lloyd broke up with the former beauty queen Ruffa Gutierrez. Although they have cleared that Shaina was not the third party why the former two broke up, many people have still speculated that it was the case. Moving on from that, their relationship has been plagued with a lot of controversies, including the Locked Up incident which also happened in the same year. This incident has made the couple the center of showbiz issues. Nonetheless, John Lloyd and Shaina stood together through it and overcame. But their relationship ended few months after that. When asked what the reason was, the two just decided to keep their mouth shut about it.